
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Intro -- Cover -- Reasons, Justification, And Defeat -- Copyright -- Contents -- List Of Contributors -- 1: Introduction -- 1.1. Introduction -- 1.2. The Nature And Extent Of Defeat -- 1.2.1 Defeaters As Reasons -- 1.2.2 Defeaters As Reliable Processes -- 1.2.3 Defeat Scepticism -- 1.2.4 Higher-order Defeat -- 1.3. Kinds Of Defeaters -- 1.3.1 By Mechanism -- 1.3.2 By Normative Status -- 1.3.3 By Psychological Status -- 1.4. Summary Of The Volume -- References -- 2: The Normativity Of Knowledge And The Scope And Sources Of Defeat -- 2.1. -- 2.2. -- 2.3. -- 2.4. -- 2.5. -- 2.6. -- References 3: The Structure Of Defeat: Pollock's Evidentialism, Lackey's Framework, And Prospects For Reliabilism -- 3.1. -- 3.2. -- 3.3. -- 3.4. -- 3.5. -- References -- 4: Losing Knowledge By Thinking About Thinking -- 4.1. Justification And The Basis Of A Judgment -- 4.2. The Function Of Subjective Representations Of Basis -- 4.3. Defeat Cases, And Shifts Of Basis -- References -- 5: Dispositional Evaluations And Defeat -- 5.1. Success And Good Dispositions -- 5.2. Ways And Dispositions -- 5.3. Dispositional Evaluations -- 5.4. Putative Defeat And Dispositional Discrimination 5.5. A Better Feasible Disposition -- 5.6. Contrast With Instrumentalist Views -- 5.7. Conclusions -- References -- 6: Suspension, Higher-order Evidence, And Defeat -- 6.1. Introduction -- 6.2. Extremism, Moderation, And A New Third Way -- 6.2.1 Extremism And Moderation -- 6.2.2 Making Room For Moderation -- 6.3. Higher-order Evidence And Reasons To Suspend -- 6.3.1 When The Evidence Gives Out -- 6.3.2 The Nature Of Suspension And What It Tells Us About The Rational Profile Of Suspension -- 6.4. A Wondrous Resolution -- 6.5. The Substantive Options For A Finer Resolution -- 6.6. Conclusion 7: Reasons For Reliabilism -- 7.1. Two Approaches To Justification -- 7.2. The Classic Reliabilist Account Of Defeat -- 7.2.1 Why Reliabilists Need An Account Of Defeat -- 7.2.2 The Arp Account Of Defeat -- 7.3. Difficulties For Th
This volume investigates the complex mechanisms of epistemic defeat, specifically addressing how new information or evidence can undermine the justification of a previously held belief. The editors, Jessica Brown and Mona Simion, curate a collection of essays from leading philosophers who examine the normative status of knowledge, the role of higher-order evidence, and the structural requirements for rational belief maintenance. By synthesizing various perspectives—including reliabilism and evidentialism—the contributors provide a rigorous framework for understanding how agents should respond when their epistemic foundations are challenged.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Experts identify this collection as a significant contribution to contemporary analytic epistemology, particularly regarding the debate over higher-order evidence. Readers frequently note the high level of academic density, making it a text primarily intended for graduate-level researchers and professional philosophers.
Page Count:
305
Publication Date:
2021-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press,
ISBN-10:
0192586483
ISBN-13:
9780192586483
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!