
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Keller (1998) reexamines Coe and Helpman’s (1995) analysis of international R&D spillovers focusing on the weights used to define the foreign R&D capital stock. Keller creates “random” weights and shows that they give rise to positive estimates of international R&D spillovers, casting doubts on the robustness of Coe and Helpman’s findings. We show that Keller’s “random” weights are essentially simple averages with a random error. We derive alternative random weights and present regressions showing that when they are used to define the foreign R&D capital stock, the estimated international R&D spillover estimates are nonexistent, as would be expected.
This paper investigates the robustness of international R&D spillover estimates by re-examining the weighting methodologies used in previous analyses. The authors address concerns raised by Keller (1998) regarding the use of 'random' weights in defining foreign R&D capital stock, which had previously suggested positive spillover effects. By deriving and applying alternative random weights, this study demonstrates that the estimated international R&D spillovers become nonexistent, aligning with theoretical expectations and challenging the conclusions drawn from earlier methods.
This academic paper directly engages with and refutes findings presented by Keller (1998) concerning international R&D spillovers. The authors' core contribution lies in demonstrating that the positive spillover estimates previously observed are contingent on specific, and in their view, flawed, weighting methods. By introducing and utilizing alternative random weights, they aim to establish that such spillovers are not statistically significant, thereby questioning the robustness of prior conclusions in the field of international economics.
Page Count:
21
Publication Date:
1999-02-01
Publisher:
International Monetary Fund
ISBN-10:
1451843623
ISBN-13:
9781451843620
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!