A series of comedic complications arises when the inhabitants of a golf-obsessed community find their romantic and social ambitions thwarted by the unpredictable nature of the game. Each story follows a different protagonist attempting to navigate the intersection of love and golf, often finding themselves at the mercy of the Oldest Member, who serves as the narrator. The characters operate within the rigid social hierarchies of a country club setting, where the rules of the game are treated with more gravity than the rules of life. The narrative framework relies on the anecdotal style of the Oldest Member, who frames each tale as a cautionary lesson for the younger generation.

Readers frequently highlight the rhythmic prose and the specific brand of wit that characterizes Wodehouse's approach to the absurdity of sports. Discussion often centers on how the author uses the golf course as a microcosm for human folly and social posturing. Critics note that the pacing remains consistent across the collection, maintaining a lighthearted tone even when the characters face significant romantic setbacks. The balance of character development is secondary to the comedic mechanics of the plot, which serves to emphasize the humorous nature of the protagonists' fixations. Many readers appreciate the consistency of the narrator's voice, which provides a stable anchor for the various eccentricities displayed by the club members.