When portrait-painter Charles Honeybath visits his friend Edwin Lightfoot, he discovers a domestic crisis that quickly escalates into a baffling disappearance. Honeybath, an amateur sleuth, finds himself navigating the eccentricities of his friend's household, where Lightfoot has been role-playing as a deceased criminal. As the situation shifts from domestic tension to a genuine criminal investigation, Honeybath must determine if his own desire for a quiet life can be reconciled with the demands of the mystery. The narrative follows a traditional detective framework, emphasizing the protagonist's observational skills and internal reflections.

Readers frequently highlight the author's dry wit and the sophisticated, often playful prose style that defines the series. Discussion often centers on the balance between the lighthearted, eccentric character interactions and the underlying tension of the central mystery. Critics note that the narrative prioritizes atmosphere and character nuance over high-octane action sequences. The book is often praised for its ability to maintain a sense of intellectual curiosity while exploring the protagonist's personal motivations. Many readers appreciate the subtle irony woven throughout the investigation, which provides a distinct flavor compared to more conventional detective stories.