This collection of poems reimagines fifteen traditional medieval legends surrounding the birth of Christ. McGinley adopts a lyrical framework to explore the miraculous events of the First Christmas through the lens of folklore. The protagonist of each poem varies, ranging from humble animals to celestial beings, all tasked with witnessing or participating in the nativity. These narratives operate within a structured, rhythmic verse format, emphasizing the wonder and piety inherent in the medieval tradition. The primary conflict often involves the tension between the mundane world and the sudden, transformative arrival of the divine.

Readers frequently highlight the rhythmic quality of McGinley's verse, noting how it elevates the traditional nativity narrative into a more whimsical and accessible form. Discussion often centers on the balance between the solemnity of the subject matter and the lighthearted, folkloric tone of the poetry. Critics observe that the inclusion of illustrations complements the text, creating a cohesive aesthetic experience for the reader. The work is often cited for its ability to preserve historical storytelling traditions while maintaining a clear, engaging voice for a modern audience.