This collection investigates the multifaceted personality and intellectual habits of C.S. Lewis through the direct observations of those who knew him personally. James T. Como compiles twenty-two distinct accounts from former students, colleagues, and friends to construct a composite portrait of Lewis. The book aims to move beyond hagiography by presenting candid, often contradictory, and intimate details about his daily life, teaching style, and private character.

Scholars and enthusiasts frequently cite this work as a primary source for understanding the human side of Lewis outside of his published writing. The text is noted for its varied perspectives, which provide a balanced view of his strengths and idiosyncrasies.