A church's missing funds and unsettling letters draw Faith Fairchild into a web of long-buried secrets. When a financial discrepancy is discovered in the Aleford's First Parish Church's discretionary fund, Faith's husband, Reverend Thomas Fairchild, becomes the prime suspect due to his sole access to the account. Simultaneously, Faith is asked by her friend Pix Miller to assist Pix's ailing mother, Ursula Rowe, who has been receiving disturbing letters. These events unravel a mystery that delves into secrets dating back to the 1920s, suggesting that hidden truths can have a profound and lasting impact.

The premise sets up a classic cozy mystery with interwoven personal and financial intrigue. The narrative structure suggests a focus on character relationships and the gradual uncovering of historical secrets, typical of the genre. The pacing likely builds as Faith navigates the dual mysteries, balancing her concern for her husband with her efforts to help Ursula. The resolution is expected to tie together the past and present secrets within the community setting.