Howard Jackson analyzes forty horror films, exploring their conceptual depth beyond typical genre tropes. The book examines a diverse selection of films from 1945 to the present, spanning global cinema, to uncover the intelligence and ideas embedded within them. Jackson delves into recurring themes such as death, identity, human frailty, and the nature of reality, offering a thoughtful and affirmative perspective on the genre. Despite the dark subject matter, the collection highlights the genre's capacity for intellectual engagement and surprising insights.

The book is praised for its insightful and entertaining analysis of horror films, with reviewers noting Howard Jackson's well-read and thoughtful approach. Critics highlight his ability to uncover surprising elements that encourage viewers and readers to reconsider the genre. The review from Crime Chronicles specifically calls 'Horror Pickers' an essential read, particularly for its examination of 'Amour'. The overall perspective suggests a work that is both intellectually stimulating and enjoyable for fans and critics of horror cinema.