A curated collection of the year's most compelling comic narratives emerges from diverse sources. This anthology gathers stories from graphic novels, pamphlet comics, newspapers, magazines, mini-comics, and the internet, showcasing the breadth of the medium. It features contributions from established artists and writers, presenting a cross-section of contemporary comic art. The collection aims to highlight significant works and emerging voices within the American comics landscape.

This inaugural volume of The Best American Comics was met with critical acclaim, earning a starred review from Kirkus Reviews, which deemed it a "worthy launch for what appears destined to become a valuable annual anthology." The collection's strength lies in its diverse sourcing, pulling from a wide array of formats to present a comprehensive view of the year's best comic work. The inclusion of prominent artists alongside a broader selection of sources suggests a commitment to both established excellence and the exploration of the medium's varied expressions. The anthology serves as a significant marker for the state of American comics at the time of its publication.