
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
This book proposes a taxonomy of jurisprudence and legal practice, based on the discourse theory of Jacques Lacan. In the anglophone academy, the positivist jurisprudence of H.L.A. Hart provides the most influential account of law. But just as positivism ignores the practice of law by lawyers, even within the academy, the majority of professors are also not pursuing Hart's positivist project. Rather, they are engaged in policy-oriented scholarship - that tries to explain law in terms of society's collective goals - or in doctrinal legal scholarship - that does not try to describe what law is, or to supply justifications for it - but which examines the 'internal' logic of law. Lacan's discourse theory has the power to differentiate the various roles of the practicing lawyer and the legal scholar. It is also able to explain the striking lack of communication between diverse schools of legal scholarship and between legal academia and the legal profession. Although extremely influential in Europe and South America, Lacanian theory remains largely unexplored (in the English-speaking world) outside of the field of comparative literature. In taking up the jurisprudential ramifications of Lacan's work, The Four Lacanian Discourses thus constitutes an original contribution to current theoretical and practical understandings of law.
This book investigates the applicability of Jacques Lacan’s discourse theory to the taxonomy of jurisprudence and the practical realities of legal scholarship. Author Jeanne Lorraine Schroeder, a legal scholar, argues that Lacanian theory provides a necessary framework to bridge the communication gap between disparate schools of legal thought. By contrasting Lacan’s discourse theory with the dominant positivist jurisprudence of H.L.A. Hart, the text seeks to explain the disconnect between academic legal theory and the actual practice of law by professionals. The work posits that legal scholarship often oscillates between policy-oriented goals and internal doctrinal logic, both of which can be better understood through a psychoanalytic lens.
What You Will Find
Experts recognize this work as a significant effort to introduce Lacanian psychoanalytic theory into the English-speaking legal academy. Readers frequently note the high level of theoretical density and the specialized knowledge required to engage with the author's synthesis of psychoanalysis and jurisprudence.
Page Count:
199
Publication Date:
2008-01-01
Publisher:
Birbeck Law Press
ISBN-10:
0203893654
ISBN-13:
9780203893654
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!