
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
They Were Expendable is the greatest American film of the Second World War, made by America's greatest director, John Ford, who himself saw action from the Battle of Midway through D-day. Yet it's been oddly neglected. Or perhaps not so oddly: for as the matter-of-fact title implies, the film commemorates a period, from the eve of Pearl Harbor up to the impending fall of Bataan, when the Japanese conquest of the Pacific was in full cry and U.S. forces were fighting a desperate holding action. Although stirring movies had been made about these early days (Wake Island, Bataan, Air Force), they were gung ho in their resolve to see the tables turned. They Were Expendable, however, which was made when Allied victory was all but assured, is profoundly elegiac, with the patient grandeur of a tragic poem. "They" are the officers and men of the Navy's PT boat service, an experimental motor-torpedo force relegated to courier duty on Manila Bay but eventually proven effective in combat. Their commander is played by Robert Montgomery, who actually served on a PT and later commanded a destroyer at Normandy; James Agee called his "the one unimprovable performance" of 1945. In addition to giving it, Montgomery codirected the breathtaking second-unit action sequences (and took over the first unit for a week when Ford broke his leg). John Wayne's costarring role as Montgomery's volatile second-in-command initially looks stereotypically blustery, but as the drama unfolds--the death of comrades, a friendship-that-never-gets-to-be-a-romance with an Army nurse (Donna Reed)--Wayne sounds notes of tenderness and vulnerability that will take Duke-bashers by surprise. They Were Expendable is a heartbreakingly beautiful film, full of astonishing images of warfare, grief, courage, and dignity: the artificial "rainfall" that lashes the beached Wayne as his PT boat explodes in the surf; the glow around a communally improvised dinner for n
A desperate holding action against overwhelming odds defines the early days of the Pacific theater in World War II. The film follows the officers and men of the Navy's PT boat service, initially relegated to courier duty, as they fight a losing battle against the Japanese conquest. Their commander, played by Robert Montgomery, must navigate the physical constraints of a losing war and the emotional toll of losing comrades, while John Wayne's character grapples with the loss of his boat and a burgeoning, unfulfilled connection with an Army nurse.
They Were Expendable is widely regarded as a significant, though sometimes overlooked, American film of World War II. Critics at the time, such as James Agee, praised Robert Montgomery's performance as "the one unimprovable performance" of 1945. The film's elegiac tone and its focus on the desperate early days of the Pacific conflict distinguish it from more jingoistic war movies. Its depiction of warfare, grief, courage, and dignity, coupled with striking imagery, contributes to its lasting impact, even if it has been less frequently discussed than other films from the era.
Page Count:
0
Publication Date:
1999-01-01
Publisher:
Mgm (video & Dvd)
ISBN-10:
0792841689
ISBN-13:
9780792841685
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!