The book investigates the integrity and influence of film criticism in the early 20th century. This volume presents a collection of P. S. Harrison's weekly newsletter reviews from 1935-1937, a period when he claimed his reviewing service was free from the influence of film advertising. Harrison's work offers outspoken critiques of films and addresses significant industry issues of the era, such as block booking and censorship. The content also includes supplementary materials like letters and Chicago Legion of Decency classifications, providing a multifaceted view of the film landscape.

This collection is recommended for large cinema collections, serving as a useful history of major industry developments from a critical perspective. The newsletter's claim of independence from film advertising is supported by Harrison's blunt opinions on industry practices. The inclusion of indexes and release date lists enhances its utility for researchers. The volume provides insight into the critical discourse and business practices of Hollywood during a pivotal era.