A festive Christmas pageant at a secluded manor turns into a crime scene when a performer vanishes into the snowy night. Artist Troy Alleyn, present to paint a portrait, finds herself amidst a house party of eccentric guests and a staff composed entirely of paroled murderers. When the disappearance occurs, the tension escalates as the guests realize the danger lurking within the estate. Inspector Roderick Alleyn is called to the scene to navigate the complex social dynamics and uncover the truth hidden behind the holiday facade. The narrative follows a traditional whodunit structure, focusing on the interplay between the isolated setting and the suspicious cast of characters.

This novel is widely regarded as a quintessential example of the Golden Age detective tradition, showcasing the author's signature wit and attention to social detail. Readers often highlight the clever premise of utilizing paroled convicts as household staff, which adds a layer of suspense to the holiday setting. The interplay between Troy and Roderick Alleyn provides a consistent anchor for the series, offering a familiar perspective amidst the unfolding chaos. Critics frequently note the precise prose and the atmospheric construction of the manor, which remains a hallmark of the author's style. The book is appreciated for its ability to balance lighthearted seasonal themes with the darker mechanics of a murder investigation.