
Between Sanity and Madness: Mental Illness from Ancient Greece to the Neuroscientific Era examines several perennial issues about mental illness: how different societies have distinguished mental disorders from normality; whether mental illnesses are similar to or different from organic conditions; and the ways in which different eras conceive of the causes of mental disorder. It begins with the earliest depictions of mental illness in Ancient Greek literature, philosophy, and medicine and concludes with the portrayals found in modern neuroscience. In contrast to the tremendous advances other branches of medicine display in answering questions about the nature, causes, and treatments of physical diseases, current psychiatric knowledge about what qualities of madness distinguish it from sanity, the resemblance of mental and physical pathologies, and the kinds of factors that lead people to become mentally ill does not show any steady growth or, arguably, much progress. The immense recent technological advances in brain science have not yet led to corresponding improvements in understandings of and explanations for mental illnesses. These perplexing phenomena remain almost as mysterious now as they were millennia ago.
This book investigates why psychiatric understanding of mental illness has failed to achieve the linear progress seen in other medical fields despite millennia of inquiry. Allan V. Horwitz, a professor of sociology, utilizes a historical and comparative framework to analyze how societies from Ancient Greece to the modern neuroscientific era have defined, categorized, and attempted to treat mental disorders. He argues that the lack of consensus on the nature of madness persists because mental illness remains fundamentally distinct from organic physical pathology.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Experts recognize this work as a significant contribution to the sociology of psychiatry and the history of medicine. Readers frequently note the academic density of the prose and the author's rigorous challenge to the assumption that technological progress in neuroscience automatically equates to a deeper understanding of mental health.
Page Count:
384
Publication Date:
2019-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0190907886
ISBN-13:
9780190907884
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!