
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Deliberative Democracy Has Challenged Two Widely-accepted Nostrums About Democratic Politics: That People Lack The Capacities For Effective Self-government; And That Democratic Procedures Are Arbitrary And Do Not Reflect Popular Will; Indeed, That The Idea Of Popular Will Is Itself Illusory. On The Contrary, Deliberative Democrats Have Shown That People Are Capable Of Being Sophisticated, Creative Problem Solvers, Given The Right Opportunities In The Right Kinds Of Democratic Institutions. But Deliberative Empirical Research Has Its Own Problems. In This Book Two Leading Deliberative Scholars Review Decades Of That Research And Reveal Three Important Issues. First, The Concept 'deliberation' Has Been Inflated So Much As To Lose Empirical Bite; Second, Deliberation Has Been Equated With Entire Processes Of Which It Is Just One Feature; And Third, Such Processes Are Confused With Democracy In A Deliberative Mode More Generally. In Other Words, Studies Frequently Apply Micro-level Tools And Concepts To Make Macro- And Meso-level Judgements, And Vice Versa. Instead, Bächtiger And Parkinson Argue That Deliberation Must Be Understood As Contingent, Performative, And Distributed. They Argue That Deliberation Needs To Be Disentangled From Other Communicative Modes; That Appropriate Tools Need To Be Deployed At The Right Level Of Analysis; And That Scholars Need To Be Clear About Whether They Are Making Additive Judgements Or Summative Ones. They Then Apply That Understanding To Set Out A New Agenda And New Empirical Tools For Deliberative Empirical Scholarship At The Micro, Meso, And Macro Levels.
How can researchers effectively measure and analyze deliberation within democratic systems without falling into conceptual inflation or scale-related errors? André Bächtiger and John M. Parkinson, both established scholars in the field of deliberative democracy, examine the current state of empirical research. They argue that the field suffers from a lack of conceptual precision, specifically regarding the conflation of micro-level interactions with macro-level democratic outcomes, and propose a new framework to align analytical tools with the appropriate levels of political analysis.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Experts in political science and democratic theory view this work as a necessary intervention for refining the empirical study of deliberation. Readers frequently note the academic density of the prose, which is intended for scholars and advanced students seeking to improve the rigor of their research methodologies.
Page Count:
224
Publication Date:
2019-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0191652350
ISBN-13:
9780191652356
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!