This work serves as a direct refutation of James Anthony Froude's prejudiced views on West Indian self-governance. John Jacob Thomas, an outraged contemporary, meticulously dismantles Froude's racist arguments presented in 'The English in the West Indies.' Thomas counters Froude's assertion that Black populations would elect oppressive leaders, thereby challenging the notion that self-governance would lead to the suppression of white inhabitants.

This work is regarded as a significant historical document, offering a powerful counter-narrative to colonialist and racist ideologies of the late 19th century. It stands as a testament to the intellectual resistance against prejudiced views on self-determination. The book provides crucial insight into the socio-political discourse surrounding the British West Indies and the fight for autonomy. Its value lies in its direct engagement with and refutation of Froude's controversial assertions.