
Examining a central assumption widely accepted as being crucial in making democracy work - that politicians form a more or less accurate image of public opinion and take that perception into account when representing citizens - Politicians' Reading of Public Opinion and its Biases presents a paradox of representation. On the one hand, politicians invest enormously in reading public opinion. They are committed to finding out what the people want and public opinion is a key consideration in many of their undertakings. Yet, on the other hand, politicians' perceptions of public opinion are surprisingly inaccurate. Politicians are hardly better at estimating public opinion than ordinary citizens are. Their perceptions are distorted by social projection, in the sense that politicians' own opinion affects their estimations, and on top of that, there seems to be a systematic right-wing bias in these perceptions. The findings imply that one of the main paths to responsive policy-making is flawed. Even though politicians do the best they can to learn about people's preferences, skewed perceptions put them on the wrong track. From a democratic perspective, the central findings of the book are quite sobering. The high hopes that many authors had with regard to politicians' ability to adequately 'consult' or 'sense' public opinion appear to be vain. The book puts forward a plausible driver of the slippage between the public and politics. Politicians are less responsive to people's preferences than they could be, not because they do not want to be responsive but because they base themselves on erroneous public opinion perceptions.
This book investigates the paradox of political representation by questioning whether politicians can accurately perceive public opinion and if their estimations align with the preferences of the citizens they represent. The authors, Julie Sevenans, Karolin Soontjens, and Stefaan Walgrave, utilize empirical research to analyze how politicians gather information about public sentiment. They argue that despite significant investment in monitoring public opinion, politicians' perceptions are frequently inaccurate and systematically biased by their own political leanings and a right-wing skew. This discrepancy suggests that the mechanism of responsive policy-making is fundamentally flawed due to cognitive and ideological distortions.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Experts in political science recognize this work as a significant contribution to the study of democratic representation and political psychology. Readers frequently note the academic rigor of the methodology and the sobering implications the findings hold for modern representative governance.
Page Count:
336
Publication Date:
2022-01-01
Publisher:
OUP Oxford
ISBN-10:
0192690876
ISBN-13:
9780192690876
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!