Deborah Matson faces a crisis of identity and morality when an illicit affair results in an unexpected pregnancy and the revelation of her lover's marriage. Deborah navigates a series of romantic entanglements that challenge her social standing and personal integrity. After discovering Brian Hayne is already married, she must reconcile her feelings for him with the reality of her impending motherhood. The narrative follows her search for stability and genuine connection, eventually leading her to Uan Palisser and Adrian Penarth. The story utilizes an epistolary framework, as Deborah documents her history in a manuscript intended for Adrian to read.

Readers often note the classic romantic style characteristic of Netta Muskett's mid-century writing. Discussion frequently centers on the protagonist's difficult choices and the moral weight of her decisions regarding her past. Critics highlight the atmospheric shift when the narrative moves to the convent, providing a quiet space for the character to process her experiences. The pacing is described as steady, focusing more on internal character development than external action. Readers appreciate the focus on the complexities of honesty within romantic relationships.