
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
The Primary Structural Purpose Of The United States Constitution Is To Empower The Federal Government To Solve Problems That The States Would Need To Act Collectively To Solve, And To Prevent The States From Undermining These Solutions Or Causing Such Problems From The Perspective Of The Constitution Or Congress. Any Faithful Account Of What The Constitution Is For And How It Should Be Interpreted Must Include This Main Structural Function. The Constitution Was Established Principally Because Of The Widely Recognized Failures Of Its Predecessor, The Articles Of Confederation, To Adequately Address Collective-action Problems Facing The States, Including Funding The National Government, Regulating Foreign And Interstate Commerce, And Defending The Nation From Attack. These Challenges Are Called Collective-action Problems Because The States Would Need To Cooperate Or Coordinate Their Behavior-they Would Need To Act Collectively, Not Individually-to Solve Them, And They Would Often Struggle To Do So. In A Fundamental Sense, The U.s. Constitution Is The Collective-action Constitution, And The Sobering Problems Facing America Today-including Inadequate Access To Health Care, Climate Change, The Covid-19 Pandemic And Future Ones, Opioid Addiction, Gun Violence, Racism And Other Bigotry, Political Extremism, Unlawful Immigration, Terrorism, And Nuclear Proliferation-cannot Be Adequately Dealt With By Government If Americans Do Not Recognize This Truth. The Main Goal Of The Collective-action Constitution Is Not To Vindicate A Conception Of Economic Efficiency, But To Create And Maintain Political And Economic Union.
Does the United States Constitution function primarily as a mechanism to resolve collective-action problems that individual states cannot manage independently? Neil S. Siegel, a professor of law and political science, argues that the document was designed specifically to overcome the failures of the Articles of Confederation by empowering a federal government to coordinate national responses. He posits that modern crises, ranging from public health to climate change, require a return to this original structural understanding to ensure effective governance and national unity.
What You Will Find
Legal scholars and political analysts view this work as a significant contribution to constitutional theory, particularly for its focus on structural functionality over ideological interpretation. Readers often note that the text provides a clear, accessible framework for understanding how historical governance challenges continue to shape modern policy debates.
Page Count:
0
Publication Date:
2024-01-01
Publisher:
New York : Oxford University Press,
ISBN-10:
0197760996
ISBN-13:
9780197760994
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!