
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
In Western Europe and North America the idea that war can deliberately be used as an "instrument of policy" has become unfashionable, not least because of the carnage of two World Wars and the Americans' humiliating experience in Vietnam. But wars are still fought. Those who start wars clearly believe they are worthwhile. Why? In this original study, Brian Bond discusses the successes and failures of military and political leaders in their pursuit of victory over the last two centuries.Professor Bond argues that in order to be counted victorious, a leader has to progress beyond military triumph to preserve the political control needed to secure an advantageous and enduring peace settlement. Napoleon was a brilliant general, but failed as a statesman. Bismarck, on the other hand, was a success in skillfully exploiting Moltlike's victories on the battlefield to create a unified Germany. In the First World War, Germany and her allies were defeated but at such great cost that confidence in the idea that war could be controlled, and the pursuit of victory made rational, received a terrible shock. Germany and Japan exploited their military opportunities between 1939 and 1942, but lack of political control and moderation brought them catastrophic defeat. After 1945, nuclear weapons and the increased complexity of international relations blurred the identity of "victors" and "losers" and seemed to make the idea of a "decisive" victory almost unthinkable. But this study warns against the assumption that war as an instrument of policy has now been completely discarded. The Falklands and Gulf conflicts show that aggressors are still prepared to risk war for tangible goals, and that their opponents are quite capable of responding successfully to such challenges.
This book investigates the historical efficacy of war as a rational instrument of policy by examining the relationship between military triumph and political stability. Brian Bond, a distinguished military historian, utilizes two centuries of conflict data to argue that true victory requires leaders to translate battlefield success into enduring, advantageous peace settlements. He contrasts the strategic failures of figures like Napoleon with the calculated successes of statesmen like Bismarck to demonstrate the necessity of political moderation in the pursuit of national objectives.
What You Will Find
Experts recognize this work as a significant contribution to the study of civil-military relations and the philosophy of war. Readers frequently note the clarity of Bond's historical synthesis and his ability to bridge the gap between battlefield tactics and high-level statecraft.
Page Count:
268
Publication Date:
1998-05-21
Publisher:
Clarendon Press
ISBN-10:
0198207352
ISBN-13:
9780198207351
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!