
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
This book has a completely original theme, or set of themes. It offers first a new way of analyzing styles of legal reasoning--between more "formal" and more "substantive" styles--that is a major contribution to jurisprudence in its own right. The authors then go on to demonstrate in detail the differences in legal reasoning--and in the legal systems as a whole--between England and America, and suggest that the English is a much more "formal" system and the American a more "substantive." Finally, the book explores a wide range of cultural, institutional, and historical factors relating to the two legal systems.
This work investigates the fundamental divergence between English and American legal systems by analyzing the tension between formal and substantive styles of legal reasoning. The authors, P. S. Atiyah and Robert S. Summers, utilize their extensive expertise in jurisprudence to construct a comparative framework that categorizes legal systems based on their reliance on rigid rules versus purposive, substantive outcomes. By examining the interplay between legal theory and institutional practice, they argue that England maintains a predominantly formalist approach, whereas the American system prioritizes substantive reasoning.
What You Will Find
Legal scholars and practitioners frequently cite this text as a foundational contribution to comparative jurisprudence and the study of legal reasoning. Experts note that the authors provide a rigorous, academic analysis that remains essential for understanding the structural differences between Anglo-American legal traditions.
Page Count:
464
Publication Date:
1987-11-12
Publisher:
Clarendon Press
ISBN-10:
0198255772
ISBN-13:
9780198255772
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!