
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Ernest Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, And William Faulkner Stand As The American Voice Of The Great War. But Was It Warfare That Drove Them To Write? Not According To Keith Gandal, Who Argues That The Authors' Famous Postwar Novels Were Motivated Not By Their Experiences Of The Horrors Of War But Rather By Their Failure To Have Those Experiences. These 'quintessential' Male American Novelists Of The 1920s Were All, For Different Reasons, Deemed Unsuitable As Candidates For Full Military Service Or Command. As A Result, Gandal Contends, They Felt Themselves Emasculated--not, As The Usual Story Goes, Due To Their Encounters With Trench Warfare, But Because They Got Nowhere Near The Real Action. Bringing To Light Previously Unexamined Army Records, Including New Information About The Intelligence Tests, The Gun And The Pen Demonstrates That The Authors' Frustrated Military Ambitions Took Place In The Forgotten Context Of The Unprecedented U.s. Mobilization For The Great War, A Radical Effort To Transform The Army Into A Meritocratic Institution, Indifferent To Ethnic And Class Difference (though Not To Racial Difference). For These Lost Generation Writers, The Humiliating Failure Vis-à-vis The Army Meant An Embarrassment Before Women And An Inability To Compete Successfully In A Rising Social Order, Against A New Set Of People. The Gun And The Pen Restores These Seminal Novels To Their Proper Historical Context And Offers A Major Revision Of Our Understanding Of America's Postwar Literature.
Does the perceived trauma of World War I truly account for the thematic preoccupation with masculinity in the works of Hemingway, Fitzgerald, and Faulkner? Keith Gandal, a scholar of American literature, challenges the long-standing critical consensus that these authors were driven by the horrors of trench warfare. Instead, he argues that their literary output was fundamentally shaped by their failure to serve in combat, which they perceived as a profound personal and social emasculation. By analyzing military records and the socio-political climate of U.S. mobilization, Gandal posits that these writers were reacting to their exclusion from the meritocratic military ideal of the era.
What You Will Find
Scholars and critics recognize this work as a significant intervention in the study of Lost Generation literature, noting its reliance on archival evidence to challenge established biographical narratives. Readers frequently highlight the book's ability to shift the focus from psychological trauma to the sociological pressures of class and gender performance in early 20th-century America.
Page Count:
288
Publication Date:
2008-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press, Incorporated
ISBN-10:
0199713383
ISBN-13:
9780199713387
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!