This book investigates the complex and often contentious relationship between civilian oversight and police accountability. Andrew John Goldsmith, a noted scholar in criminology and policing, examines the historical development and contemporary challenges of civilian review boards and other oversight mechanisms. The work analyzes various models of oversight, drawing on case studies and theoretical frameworks to argue for more effective and legitimate structures that can enhance public trust and police legitimacy.

The book is recognized as a significant contribution to the literature on policing and governance, offering a comprehensive overview of civilian oversight mechanisms. Its detailed analysis and comparative approach provide valuable insights for academics, policymakers, and practitioners interested in improving police accountability and community relations. The work is considered a foundational text for understanding the complexities of civilian review.