Does the combination of human rationality and consciousness provide a basis for free will that is compatible with an indeterministic view of the universe? David Hodgson, drawing upon his background in legal theory and philosophy of mind, argues that human beings possess a capacity to respond to complex conscious experiences in ways that transcend simple computational rules or strict physical determinism. He posits that this framework aligns with contemporary scientific understanding while addressing the ethical implications of human agency and moral responsibility.

Critics and scholars frequently characterize Hodgson's work as intellectually rigorous and balanced, noting his ability to synthesize complex scientific concepts with philosophical inquiry. Experts often highlight the text as a significant contribution to the ongoing debate regarding agency and the limitations of physical determinism.