
Women and the LGBT community in Russia and Turkey face pervasive discrimination. Only a small percentage dare to challenge their mistreatment in court. Facing domestic police and judges who often refuse to recognize discrimination, a small minority of activists have exhausted their domestic appeals and then turned to their last hope: the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). The ECtHR, located in Strasbourg, France, is widely regarded as the most effective international human rights court in existence. Russian citizens whose rights have been violated at home have brought tens of thousands of cases to the ECtHR over the past two decades. But only one of these cases resulted in a finding of gender discrimination by the ECtHR-and that case was brought by a man. By comparison, the Court has found gender discrimination more frequently in decisions on Turkish cases. Courting Gender Justice explores the obstacles that confront citizens, activists, and lawyers who try to bring gender discrimination cases to court. To shed light on the factors that make rare victories possible in discrimination cases, the book draws comparisons among forms of discrimination faced by women and LGBT people in Russia and Turkey. Based on interviews with human rights and feminist activists and lawyers in Russia and Turkey, this engaging book grounds the law in the personal experiences of individual people fighting to defend their rights.
This book investigates why gender discrimination cases against Russia and Turkey rarely succeed at the European Court of Human Rights despite the court's reputation for effectiveness. The authors, Lisa McIntosh Sundstrom, Melike Sayoglu, and Valerie Sperling, utilize a comparative framework to analyze the legal and political barriers faced by activists in these two nations. By grounding their research in qualitative interviews with lawyers and human rights advocates, they examine the systemic failures of domestic judicial systems and the specific challenges of litigating gender-based grievances at the international level.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Experts identify this work as a significant contribution to the study of international human rights law and the practical limitations of supranational courts. Readers frequently note the balance between rigorous academic analysis and the inclusion of personal narratives from those navigating these complex legal systems.
Page Count:
302
Publication Date:
2019-03-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
019093283X
ISBN-13:
9780190932831
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!