Graham Cavanaugh finds himself caught between two vastly different women, questioning his choices in love and marriage. His current wife, Audra, is a whirlwind of spontaneous energy and unconventional behavior, while his first wife, Elspeth, reenters his life, forcing him to confront the complexities of their past and the nature of his present. Navigating the daily challenges of raising a child with Asperger's and the reemergence of a former spouse, Graham grapples with the profound question of how one can love two such disparate individuals and whether he made the right marital choice.

This novel is characterized by its rueful and humorous examination of marital dynamics and personal choices. The narrative blends hilarity with heartbreak, drawing comparisons to authors known for their witty and insightful explorations of relationships. The book delves into the complexities of loving different people and the lingering questions that arise from past relationships. It offers a sharp, funny, and poignant look at the realities of marriage and family life.