
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
An excellent book. Takagi takes a very complex and sensitive subject--racial politics--and shows, through a careful analysis... that changes in the discourse about Asian American admissions have facilitated a 'retreat from race' in the area of affirmative action.... This book will appeal to an audience significantly wider than a typical academic one."-- David Karen, Bryn Mawr College Charges by Asian Americans that the top universities in the United States used quotas to limit the enrollment of Asian-American students developed into one of the most controversial public controversies in higher education since the Bakke case. In Retreat from Race, Dana Takagi follows the debates over Asian-American admissions at Berkeley, UCLA, Brown, Stanford, Harvard, and Princeton. She explains important developments in the politics of race: changes in ethnic coalitions, reconstruction of the debate over affirmative action, and the conservative challenge to the civil rights agenda of the 1960s. Takagi examines the history and significance of the Asian American admissions controversy on American race relations both inside and outside higher education. Takagi's central argument is that the Asian-American admissions controversy facilitated a subtle but important shift in affirmative action policy away from racial preferences toward class preferences. She calls this development a retreat from race. Takagi suggests that the retreat signals not only an actual policy shift but also the increasing reluctance on the part of intellectuals, politicans, and policy analysts to identify and address social problems as explicitly racial problems. Moving beyond the university setting, Takagi explores the political significance of the retreat from race by linking Asian-American admissions to other controversies in higher education and in American politics, including the debates over political correctness and multiculturalism. In her assessment, the retreat f
The central question of this book is how the controversy surrounding Asian American admissions to elite universities facilitated a shift in affirmative action policy and public discourse regarding race. Dana Y. Takagi, drawing on her expertise in sociology and race relations, meticulously analyzes the debates at institutions like Berkeley, UCLA, Brown, Stanford, Harvard, and Princeton. She argues that this controversy led to a 'retreat from race,' moving policy away from racial preferences towards class-based considerations, and reflects a broader societal reluctance to address social problems as explicitly racial issues. The book connects these admissions debates to wider controversies in higher education and American politics, such as those concerning political correctness and multiculturalism.
The book is regarded as an excellent and important contribution to the study of race and higher education. Critics highlight Takagi's careful analysis of a complex and sensitive subject, noting its appeal to a wide audience beyond academia. The work is praised for its thorough examination of the debates surrounding Asian American admissions and their implications for affirmative action policy and the broader discourse on race in America. It is recognized for its insightful connection of these specific university controversies to larger political and cultural discussions.
Page Count:
246
Publication Date:
1992-01-01
Publisher:
Rutgers University Press
ISBN-10:
0813519136
ISBN-13:
9780813519135
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!