
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
The current official poverty measure provides individuals and policy makers with information about the types of families and people who are not making ends meet. One important dimension along which this information is provided has to do with where people live. It is quite obvious to all that consider it that the cost of living is different depending upon where you live. But here we find one of the more contentious issues in measuring poverty, how to accurately portray the difficulty of making ends meet when the cost of basic necessities varies widely for people living in different places. The current official poverty measure makes no adjustments for geographic area. It presents the cost of getting along as uniform across the United States. Poverty rates by state, for example, as shown in the first figure, are calculated using the same poverty thresholds regardless of where you live. In her book on measuring poverty, Patricia Ruggles (1990) wrote that, "Other than differences in family size and type, the major source of possible differences in need that analysts have considered as a basis for adjustment are differences in place of residence." Ruggles provided evidence that a strong case can be made for adjustment of the poverty thresholds for price differences by geographic area. She argued that, even though we cannot make precise adjustments for very small areas, we quite possibly would make fewer errors if reasonable adjustments were made for larger geographic areas. The challenge then is, as Ruggles stated, "the analyst must balance the possibility that a given adjustment will distort needs estimates in some cases against the potential error that may results if no adjustment is done." In her view, "...the evidence for real differences in price levels across regions has become too compelling to ignore."
The official poverty measure fails to account for geographic cost-of-living differences, creating a uniform standard across diverse economic landscapes. This paper investigates the implications of this uniformity, particularly how the current poverty thresholds, which do not adjust for location, present a potentially inaccurate picture of hardship. It examines the arguments for and against adjusting poverty thresholds for geographic price variations, referencing Patricia Ruggles's work which suggests that such adjustments, even if imperfect for small areas, could lead to more accurate poverty estimates for larger regions. The core challenge lies in balancing the risk of distorting estimates with the potential errors introduced by ignoring demonstrable regional price differences.
This working paper critically examines the methodology of the official poverty measure, specifically its failure to incorporate geographic cost-of-living variations. It highlights the contentious nature of this issue within poverty research and policy-making, referencing established scholarship to support the case for regional adjustments. The paper frames the central problem as a methodological challenge requiring careful consideration of potential distortions versus the inaccuracies of ignoring real price differences. The analysis suggests that while precise adjustments are difficult, ignoring significant regional price disparities may lead to a less accurate representation of poverty.
Page Count:
24
Publication Date:
2013-03-22
Publisher:
BiblioGov
ISBN-10:
1288962266
ISBN-13:
9781288962266
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!