
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Can unexpressed thoughts be morally wrong? Are people subject to moral condemnation not only for their malicious, biased, and cruel actions, but also for their private malice, biased beliefs, and ugly fantasies? Although many would answer "yes," George Sher argues in A Wild West of the Mind that none of the main approaches to morality support this view and that to accept it would be to relinquish an essential aspect of our mental freedom. To preserve that freedom, we must allow our beliefs to follow the evidence wherever it leads and must give our private feelings, attitudes, and fantasies free rein. As so understood, the realm of the purely mental is a morality-free zone, one within which no thoughts or attitudes are either forbidden or required. Even when our beliefs are irrational or repugnant and our desires reflect badly on our character, it is never morally wrong for us to have them. A Wild West of the Mind advances a provocative thesis of normative ethics and offers a powerful defense of freedom of mind. Broad in scope and tightly argued, the book will have much to offer philosophers working in ethics, free will, and epistemology.
Does the moral domain extend to the realm of private, unexpressed thoughts, or should the mind remain a zone free from moral condemnation? George Sher, a prominent philosopher, examines the tension between common moral intuition and the necessity of cognitive liberty. He argues that traditional ethical frameworks fail to justify the regulation of private beliefs and fantasies, positing that such regulation would fundamentally undermine the autonomy required for rational inquiry and mental freedom.
What You Will Find
Philosophers and scholars of ethics recognize this work as a rigorous contribution to the discourse on moral responsibility and cognitive freedom. The text is noted for its precise argumentation and its challenge to conventional views on the morality of internal states.
Page Count:
143
Publication Date:
2021-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0197564690
ISBN-13:
9780197564691
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!