
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
State Capacity Is Often Equated With Coercion. The Literature Suggests That Compliance With Law Is Unlikely In Areas Where The State Cannot Coerce Compliance. Utilizing Extensive Data Collected In Adjacent Districts In India And Nepal, And Exploring Three Different Regulatory Arenas, This Book Demonstrates That Coercively Weak States Can Significantly Increase Compliance By Behaving Pragmatically And Designing Implementation Around Known Barriers To Compliance. One Such Barrier Is Imperfect Legal Knowledge. Though Legal Knowledge Is Often Assumed To Be Accurate, This Assumption Is Problematic. Principal-agent Problems Prevent Many Weak States From Behaving Consistently, And Target Populations Often Lack Education And Competent Legal Advice. As A Result, They Struggle To Learn About The Law. States That Employ Regulatory Pragmatism, However, May Circumvent This Compliance Barrier. They Do So By Designing Implementation Strategies For On-the-ground Realities. The Book Explores Two Such Efforts-delegated Enforcement And Information Dissemination Through Local Leaders. The Data Indicate That Strategies Consistent With Regulatory Pragmatism, In Contrast To Those That Are Legally Doctrinaire Or Deterrence-based, Significantly Increase Legal Knowledge And Compliance, Even Where The State Is Locally Weak. This Is Demonstrated In Through A Primary Case Involving Compliance With Conservation Law, As Well As Through Two Shadow Cases Involving Compliance With Education And Child Labor Regulation-- Provided By Publisher.
This book investigates whether state capacity must rely on coercion to ensure legal compliance or if alternative regulatory frameworks can achieve similar results. Author Susan L. Ostermann, a political scientist, challenges the conventional wisdom that weak states are inherently incapable of enforcing laws. By analyzing empirical data from border regions in India and Nepal, she argues that states can overcome barriers like imperfect legal knowledge by adopting pragmatic implementation strategies. The work provides a framework for understanding how states can function effectively despite limited resources and principal-agent problems.
What You Will Find
Scholars in political science and development studies identify this work as a significant contribution to the study of state capacity and governance in the Global South. Readers frequently note the clarity of the author's methodology and the practical implications of her findings for policymakers operating in resource-constrained environments.
Page Count:
0
Publication Date:
2022-11-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press, Incorporated
ISBN-10:
0197661149
ISBN-13:
9780197661147
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!