
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Does syllogistic logic have the resources to capture mathematical proof? This volume provides the first unified account of the history of attempts to answer this question, the reasoning behind the different positions taken, and their far-reaching implications. Aristotle had claimed that scientific knowledge, which includes mathematics, is provided by syllogisms of a special sort: 'scientific' ('demonstrative') syllogisms. In ancient Greece and in the Middle Ages, the claim that Euclid's theorems could be recast syllogistically was accepted without further scrutiny. Nevertheless, as early as Galen, the importance of relational reasoning for mathematics had already been recognized. Further critical voices emerged in the Renaissance and the question of whether mathematical proofs could be recast syllogistically attracted more sustained attention over the following three centuries. Supported by more detailed analyses of Euclidean theorems, this led to attempts to extend logical theory to include relational reasoning, and to arguments purporting to reduce relational reasoning to a syllogistic form. Philosophical proposals to the effect that mathematical reasoning is heterogenous with respect to logical proofs were famously defended by Kant, and the implications of the debate about the adequacy of syllogistic logic for mathematics are at the very core of Kant's account of synthetic a priori judgments. While it is now widely accepted that syllogistic logic is not sufficient to account for the logic of mathematical proof, the history and the analysis of this debate, running from Aristotle to de Morgan and beyond, is a fascinating and crucial insight into the relationship between philosophy and mathematics.
This volume investigates whether the traditional framework of syllogistic logic possesses the necessary resources to adequately represent and capture the structure of mathematical proof. Prof. Massimo Mugnai and Prof. Paolo Mancosu provide a comprehensive historical analysis of the debate surrounding the adequacy of Aristotelian logic in the context of mathematical demonstration. By examining the evolution of logical theory from ancient Greece through the Renaissance and into the modern era, the authors evaluate how philosophers and mathematicians attempted to reconcile relational reasoning with syllogistic forms. The text explores the philosophical implications of this tension, particularly regarding Kant's account of synthetic a priori judgments and the eventual recognition of the limitations of syllogistic systems.
What You Will Find
Experts recognize this volume as a significant contribution to the history of logic and the philosophy of mathematics. Readers frequently note the academic density of the prose, which provides a rigorous examination of the evolution of logical thought.
Page Count:
240
Publication Date:
2023-08-18
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0198876920
ISBN-13:
9780198876922
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!