
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
From the late nineteenth century until World War I, a group of Columbia University students gathered under the mentorship of the renowned historian William Archibald Dunning (1857–1922). Known as the Dunning School, these students wrote the first generation of state studies on the Reconstruction -- volumes that generally sympathized with white southerners, interpreted radical Reconstruction as a mean-spirited usurpation of federal power, and cast the Republican Party as a coalition of carpetbaggers, freedmen, scalawags, and former Unionists. Edited by the award-winning historian John David Smith and J. Vincent Lowery, The Dunning School focuses on this controversial group of historians and its scholarly output. Despite their methodological limitations and racial bias, the Dunning historians' writings prefigured the sources and questions that later historians of the Reconstruction would utilize and address. Many of their pioneering dissertations remain important to ongoing debates on the broad meaning of the Civil War and Reconstruction and the evolution of American historical scholarship. This groundbreaking collection of original essays offers a fair and critical assessment of the Dunning School that focuses on the group's purpose, the strengths and weaknesses of its constituents, and its legacy. Squaring the past with the present, this important book also explores the evolution of historical interpretations over time and illuminates the ways in which contemporary political, racial, and social questions shape historical analyses. - Publisher.
The Dunning School examines the influential, yet controversial, group of historians who shaped early interpretations of the Reconstruction era. Mentored by William Archibald Dunning, these Columbia University students produced state studies that largely favored white Southern perspectives, viewing Reconstruction as a punitive federal overreach and characterizing the Republican Party through negative stereotypes. This collection of essays critically assesses their purpose, the merits and flaws of their individual contributions, and their enduring legacy on historical scholarship.
This collection offers a balanced and critical appraisal of the Dunning School, acknowledging both its methodological shortcomings and its foundational role in Reconstruction historiography. The essays explore the group's purpose, the strengths and weaknesses of its members, and its lasting impact on the study of American history. By examining the evolution of historical interpretations, the book illuminates how contemporary political and social contexts shape scholarly analysis. It provides a nuanced perspective on a pivotal, yet often debated, school of thought in American historical scholarship.
Page Count:
338
Publication Date:
2013-01-01
ISBN-10:
0813142253
ISBN-13:
9780813142258
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!