
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Peter Unger's provocative new book poses a serious challenge to contemporary analytic philosophy, arguing that to its detriment it focuses the predominance of its energy on "empty ideas."In the mid-twentieth century, philosophers generally agreed that, by contrast with science, philosophy should offer no substantial thoughts about the general nature of concrete reality. Leading philosophers were concerned with little more than the semantics of ordinary words. For example: Our word "perceives" differs from our word "believes" in that the first word is used more strictly than the second. While someone may be correct in saying "I believe there's a table before me" whether or not there is a table before her, she will be correct in saying "I perceive there's a table before me" only if there is a table there. Though just a parochial idea, whether or not it is correct does make a difference to how things are with concrete reality. In Unger's terms, it is a concretely substantial idea. Alongside each such parochial substantial idea, there is an analytic or conceptual thought, as with the thought that someone may believe there is a table before her whether or not there is one, but she will perceive there is a table before her only if there is a table there. Empty of import as to how things are with concrete reality, those thoughts are what Unger calls concretely empty ideas.It is widely assumed that, since about 1970, things had changed thanks to the advent of such thoughts as the content externalism championed by Hilary Putnam and Donald Davidson, various essentialist thoughts offered by Saul Kripke, and so on. Against that assumption, Unger argues that, with hardly any exceptions aside from David Lewis's theory of a plurality of concrete worlds, all of these recent offerings are concretely empty ideas. Except when offering parochial ideas, Peter Unger maintains that mainstream philosophy still offers hardly anything beyond concretely empty ideas.
Does contemporary analytic philosophy focus its intellectual energy on ideas that lack any substantial connection to concrete reality? Peter Unger, a prominent philosopher, examines the evolution of analytic thought from the mid-twentieth century to the present. He argues that despite claims of progress, the field remains largely preoccupied with 'concretely empty ideas'—conceptual distinctions that offer no insight into the nature of the physical world. Unger challenges the assumption that post-1970 developments, such as content externalism and essentialism, represent a shift toward substantive inquiry.
What You Will Find
Experts and critics recognize this work as a provocative critique that forces a re-examination of the methodology within analytic philosophy. Readers frequently note the dense, argumentative nature of the prose, which demands a high level of familiarity with contemporary metaphysical debates.
Page Count:
274
Publication Date:
2014-07-14
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0199330816
ISBN-13:
9780199330812
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!