
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Every day we hear about some fascinating new discovery. Yet anemic progress toward addressing the greatest risks to humankind -- clean energy, emerging infections, and cancer -- warns us that science may not be meeting its potential. Indeed, there is evidence that advances are slowing. Science is costly and can hurt people; thus it must be pursued with caution. Yet, excessive caution stifles the very thing that powers inventiveness: creation. In her boldest book yet, Roberta Ness argues that the system of funding agencies, universities, and industries designed to promote innovation has come to impede it.The Creativity Crisis strips away the scientific enterprise's veil of mystique to reveal the gritty underbelly of university research. America's economic belt-tightening discourages long-term, risky investments in revolutionary advances and elevates short-term projects with assured outcomes. The pursuit of basic research insights, with the greatest power to transform but little ability to enrich, is being abandoned. The social nature of academia today also contributes to the descent of revolutionary discovery. In academia, which tends to be insular, hierarchical, and tradition-bound, research ideas are "owned" and the owners gain enormous clout to decide what is accepted. Communalism is antithetical to idea ownership. Thus science has not embraced the Web-based democratic sharing of ideas called crowdsourcing, one of the greatest tools for creativity and social change in our age. A final battleground between creation and caution is within the sphere of ethics. Scientists are typically altruistic but sometimes have all-too-human inclinations toward avarice and conceit. The most original thinkers are most likely to flout convention. This tendency can pull them across the lines of acceptable behavior. Caution is a necessary check on the destructive potential of amoral creation. Yet, when every individual and institution is considered a priori to be a threat, adventureso
The core question investigated is why the modern scientific enterprise, despite its vast resources, is experiencing a decline in revolutionary breakthroughs and how systemic caution has stifled creative potential. Roberta B. Ness, an expert in public health and research methodology, utilizes her extensive background in academic leadership to analyze the structural barriers within universities and funding agencies. She argues that the current emphasis on short-term, low-risk outcomes and hierarchical gatekeeping prevents the pursuit of transformative basic research. The book presents a critical framework for understanding how institutional incentives and social dynamics in academia actively discourage the risk-taking necessary for scientific advancement.
What You Will Find
Experts and academics frequently cite this work as a provocative critique of the current state of institutional research. Readers note the author's clear-eyed assessment of the tension between bureaucratic safety and the inherent volatility of discovery.
Page Count:
296
Publication Date:
2014-12-30
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0199375380
ISBN-13:
9780199375387
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!