
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
The ''state secrets privilege'' is a common law rule of evidence that the Federal Government can invoke to prevent materials from being publicly disclosed in civil court proceedings, if the Governmentestablishes that such disclosure would harm the Nation. In the early 1970s, Congress considered including a state secrets provision in the Federal Rules of Evidence, but it ultimately decidednot to include any privileges.1 Although numerous laws govern the handling of classified documents and other information that may implicate state secrets in specific contexts, the state secrets privilege has never been codified in statute. The Supreme Court addressed the state secrets privilege at length for the first (and last) time in United States v. Reynolds,2 a 1953 tort suit brought by widows of civilian engineers who diedin an Air Force plane crash. The Reynolds decision has been criticized as internally contradictory and excessively deferential to the Executive,3 and commentators dispute the extent to which it is followedby lower courts today.4 Nevertheless, it remains the foundational case on the privilege and the starting point for judicial review of privilege claims. As one commentator describes it, the analyticalframework established in Reynolds comprises several basicprinciples:
The State Secrets Privilege has never been codified in statute, despite Congressional consideration in the early 1970s. This book examines the common law rule of evidence that allows the Federal Government to prevent disclosure of materials in civil proceedings if such disclosure would harm the nation. It delves into the foundational Supreme Court case, United States v. Reynolds, which has been subject to criticism and ongoing debate regarding its application by lower courts. The text explores the principles established by Reynolds and their contemporary relevance in legal discourse.
This text appears to be a detailed legal analysis of the state secrets privilege, likely intended for legal professionals, policymakers, or students of law and government. Its focus on case law and statutory history suggests a rigorous examination of a complex legal doctrine. The discussion of the Reynolds case and its ongoing interpretation indicates a work that engages with both historical precedent and contemporary legal challenges.
Page Count:
54
Publication Date:
2012-10-23
Publisher:
CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform
ISBN-10:
1480150770
ISBN-13:
9781480150775
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!