
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Cover -- Listening To Reason In Plato And Aristotle -- Copyright -- Dedication -- Contents -- Preface -- General Introduction -- Outline Of The Book -- Part One Plato's Republic -- Introduction To Part I Three Levels Of Argument -- 1: The Longer Route -- 1. Conflicting Signals -- 2. The Influence Of The Non-rational Parts -- 3. The Role Of Mathematics -- 4. Natural Philosophers -- 2: The Middle Route -- 1. The Evidence Of 493e2-494a4 -- 2. The Conversation With Glaucon: The Lovers Of Sights And Sounds -- 3. The Conversation With Adeimantus: Convincing 'the Many' 4. The Value Of Following The Middle Route -- 3: The Shorter Route -- 1. The Case For Pessimism -- (a) The Interplay Of The Characters -- (b) Considerations From Moral Psychology -- (c) The Role Of Education -- (d) Reasons For Caution -- 2. The Case For Qualified Optimism -- (a) The Evidence Of Book Ix (588b1-592b5) -- (b) A Parallel In Book Vi -- 3. Concluding Aporia -- 4: The Role Of Education -- Introduction -- 1. Exposure To Beauty In Rep. Iii 400c8-402c9 -- (a) Beauty And Reason (400c8-402a6) -- (b) The Reading Analogy (402a7-c8) -- (c) Implications 2. The Effects Of Mimetic Poetry In Rep. X -- 3. Further Exclusions -- (a) The Balance Between Music And Gymnastics (iii 410b5-412a7) -- (b) Premature Dialectic (vii 537e1-539d7) -- Conclusion -- 5: Irrationality In Republic Viii-ix: Timocracy And Oligarchy -- Introduction -- 1. The Timocrat (548d6-550c3) -- (a) The Nature And Development Of The Timocrat -- (b) How Common Is The Timocrat? -- 2. The Oligarch (553a3-555b3) -- (a) Reason And The Oligarchic Character -- (b) The Rarity Of The Oligarch -- 6: Irrationality In Republic Viii-ix: Democracy And Tyranny -- The Democrat (558c6-562a3) (a) The Junior Democrat -- (b) The Senior Democrat -- (c) The Democratic Character Reconsidered In Book Ix -- (d) How Common Is The Democrat? -- 2. The Tyrant (571a1-580a8) -- (a) Madness And The Tyrant -- (b) The Tyrant's Regret -- (c) The Rarity Of The Tyrant -- Conclusion -- Interim Conclusions -- 1. Platonic Pessimism Revisited -- 2. The Ideal State -- Part Two Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics -- Introduction To Part Ii: The Target Audience Of The Ne -- 1. The Subject Matter Of The Ne -- 2. The Ne As Political Science -- 3. The Audience -- 4. Upbringing -- 5. Aristotle's Exclusions 6. The Relation Between The Nicomachean Ethics And The Politics -- 7: The Functions Of The Nicomachean Ethics -- 1. Clarification, Conversion, And Reinforcement -- 2. The Discussion Of Pleasure In Ne X -- (a) Protreptic Intent In Ne X 1 -- (b) Protreptic Arguments In Ne X 5-6 -- 3. Self-love In Ne Ix 4 -- 8: Aristotle And Moral Scepticism -- 1. The Function Argument And The Doctrine Of The Mean -- (a) The Function Argument Of Rep. I -- (b) The Function Argument In Ne I 7 -- (c) Ne I 13 -- (d) The Doctrine Of The Mean In Ne Ii 6 -- (e) Aristotle's Intentions -- 2. Moral Scepticism And The Politics Dominic Scott. This Edition Also Issued In Print: 2020. Includes Bibliographical References And Indexes. Electronic Reproduction. Oxford Available Via World Wide Web.
This book investigates the complex relationship between reason and non-rational elements within the human psyche as presented in the works of Plato and Aristotle. Dominic Scott, a scholar of ancient philosophy, utilizes a rigorous textual analysis of the Republic and other foundational dialogues to argue that these philosophers did not view reason as an isolated faculty, but rather as one that must navigate and integrate with competing psychological drives.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Scholars frequently note the high level of academic density and the meticulous attention to specific Greek passages throughout the text. Experts highlight this work as a significant contribution to the study of moral psychology in antiquity, particularly for those interested in the pedagogical dimensions of Platonic philosophy.
Page Count:
288
Publication Date:
2020-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press,
ISBN-10:
019189575X
ISBN-13:
9780191895753
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!