
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
The Central Aim Of The Parmenidean Ascent Is To Reveal The Power Of An Extreme Monism Of A Parmenidean Variety In A More Uncompromising Manner Than Has Been Attempted For Many A Year. For The Parmenidean Monist, There Are No Distinctions Whatsoever, And Indeed Distinctions Are Unintelligible. The Book Not Only Defends-against The Tide Of Much Recent Scholarship-the Attribution Of Such A Sweeping Monism To Parmenides, It Also Embraces This Monism In Its Own Right And Expands These Monistic Results To Many Of The Most Crucial Areas Of Philosophy. The Topics That Come In For This Rationalistic, Monistic, Treatment Include Being, Action, Knowledge, Meaning, Truth, And Metaphysical Explanation. There Is Thus No Differentiated Being, No Differentiated Action, Knowledge, Etc. Rather All Is Being, Just As All Is Action, Knowledge, Etc. The Motive Force Behind This Argument Is A Combination Of A Detailed Survey Of The Failures Of Leading Positions (both Historical And Contemporary) To Meet A Demand For The Explanation Of A Given Phenomenon, And A Powerful Rationalist, Bradleyan Argument Against The Reality Of Relations. The Result Is A Rationalist Rejection Of All Distinctions And A Skeptical Denial Of The Intelligibility Of Ordinary, Relational Notions Of Being, Action, Knowledge, Etc. A Further Significant Upshot Is The Rejection Of Any Distinction Between Philosophy Itself And The Study Of Its History. Throughout The Book, Attention Is Paid To Philosophical Methods Systems, Including Especially The Method, So Popular Today, Of Relying On Intuitions And Common Sense. The Historically-minded And Rationalist Approach Throughout This Book Goes A Long Way Toward Demonstrating The Ultimate Bankruptcy Of This Prevalent Methodology-- Provided By Publisher.
The central question investigated is whether an extreme, uncompromising monism—specifically of the Parmenidean variety—can be defended as a coherent and superior alternative to contemporary philosophical methodologies. Michael Della Rocca, a prominent philosopher, utilizes a rigorous rationalist framework to argue that all distinctions are ultimately unintelligible. By critiquing the failures of both historical and modern philosophical positions to provide adequate explanations, the author posits that the reality of relations is illusory, thereby collapsing traditional categories of being, action, knowledge, and truth into a singular, undifferentiated whole.
What You Will Find
Experts recognize this work as a provocative and highly dense contribution to the field of metaphysics that challenges the prevailing analytic consensus. Readers frequently note the rigorous, uncompromising nature of the prose, which demands a high level of familiarity with both ancient Greek philosophy and modern rationalist discourse.
Page Count:
0
Publication Date:
2020-01-01
Publisher:
New York, Ny, United States Of America : Oxford University Press,
ISBN-10:
0197510949
ISBN-13:
9780197510971
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!