
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Since the publication of John Rawls's A Theory of Justice (1971) - followed up by Political Liberalism (1993) and Justice as Fairness: A Restatement (2001) - discussions on social justice and redistributive liberalism have taken center stage in contemporary political theory. This book adds to an enormous body of literature. It does not question Rawlsian principles, but it does reject the liberal institutions he advocates. A debate is constructed in which his liberalism is contrasted with a libertarian socialism informed by the English theorist of guild socialism G.D.H. Cole (1889-1959). These two authors visualize alternative macro socio-economic schemes. Although they are set within modern liberal and libertarian socialist frameworks respectively, they share a commitment to reducing vast inequalities in wealth. Central to the Rawlsian scheme is the difference principle - that inequalities are only permitted if they benefit the least well off. Rawls proposes that citizens deliberating without awareness of subjective talents - a collective lack of knowledge captured by the Rawlsian term the veil of ignorance - will be compelled to prioritize a society structured to accommodate this principle to other systems in which inequalities are allowed to concentrate with lesser degrees of regulation. This assertion will not be challenged. However, it is shown how the difference principle will be more easily realized in the left libertarian scheme, in which the author defends. The argument is that Rawlsian premises point to a more radical conclusion than Rawls acknowledges.--Bloomsbury Publishing.
This book investigates whether John Rawls's difference principle, which permits inequalities only if they benefit the least well off, can be more effectively realized within a libertarian socialist framework than within Rawls's own liberal institutional design. The author, Chris Wyatt, builds upon the extensive literature surrounding Rawls's theories of social justice, particularly A Theory of Justice, Political Liberalism, and Justice as Fairness: A Restatement. While accepting Rawls's core premises, the book contrasts Rawlsian liberalism with a libertarian socialism informed by G.D.H. Cole. The central argument posits that the difference principle, a cornerstone of Rawls's work, finds a more conducive environment for its implementation in a left libertarian scheme, suggesting that Rawls's principles ultimately point to more radical conclusions than he himself acknowledged.
The book is positioned within the substantial body of contemporary political theory that engages with John Rawls's foundational works on social justice. It is presented as a contribution that, rather than challenging Rawls's core principles, seeks to demonstrate their more effective implementation through alternative institutional arrangements. The argument centers on a comparative analysis between Rawlsian liberalism and G.D.H. Cole's libertarian socialism, suggesting that the latter offers a more robust pathway to achieving the goals of the difference principle. The work aims to show that the logical conclusions of Rawls's own premises might extend to more radical socio-economic structures than he explicitly endorsed.
Page Count:
182
Publication Date:
2008-01-01
ISBN-10:
0826429424
ISBN-13:
9780826429421
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!