To Gaurus On How Embryos Are Ensouled And On What Is In Our Power
0
0
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Author Description
Concerning embryos, Porphyry takes an original view on issues that had been left undecided by his teacher Plotinus and earlier by the doctor Galen. What role is played in the development of the embryo by the souls or the natures of the father, of the mother, of the embryo, or of the whole world? Porphyry's detailed answer, in contrast to Aristotle's, gives a significant role to the soul and to the nature of the mother, without, however, abandoning Aristotle's view that the mother supplies no seed. In the fragments of On What is in Our Power, "Porphyry" discusses Plato's idea that we choose each of our incarnations, and so are responsible for what happens in our lives. This volume contains an English translation of the two commentaries, as well as extensive notes, an introduction and a bibliography.
Menrva's Summary
THE THESIS
This volume presents a translation and analysis of Porphyry's commentaries on embryology and human agency. The text explores Porphyry's original views on the ensoulment of embryos, diverging from Aristotle by emphasizing the role of the mother's soul and nature. It also delves into Porphyry's interpretation of Plato's concept of pre-incarnation choice, which posits individual responsibility for life events. The work includes an English translation, extensive notes, an introduction, and a bibliography, offering a comprehensive scholarly resource.
THE SCOPE MAP
- English translation of Porphyry's commentaries on embryology and human agency.
- Detailed examination of Porphyry's views on the ensoulment of embryos, contrasting with Aristotle and Galen.
- Discussion of the roles of the father, mother, embryo, and world soul in embryonic development.
- Analysis of Porphyry's interpretation of Plato's theory of pre-incarnation choice and responsibility.
- Extensive scholarly notes providing context and interpretation.
- Introductory essay setting the historical and philosophical background.
- Bibliography for further research.
THE AUTHORITY PERSPECTIVE
This scholarly edition provides a vital resource for understanding Porphyry's contributions to ancient philosophical debates on embryology and free will. The detailed notes and introduction by James Wilberding offer expert guidance through complex arguments, making Porphyry's original texts accessible to a wider academic audience. The work is positioned as a significant contribution to the study of Neoplatonism and the history of philosophy. It is expected to be of interest to scholars and students of ancient thought, ethics, and the history of science.
Page Count:
176
Publication Date:
2011-01-01
ISBN-10:
0715638580
ISBN-13:
9780715638583
Classics
Non-Fiction
Philosophy
Community Tags
Similar Books
