
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Philosophy written in English is overwhelmingly analytic philosophy, and the techniques and predilections of analytic philosophy are not only unhistorical but anti-historical, and hostile to textual commentary. Analytic usually aspires to a very high degree of clarity and precision of formulation and argument, and it often seeks to be informed by, and consistent with, current natural science. In an earlier era, analytic philosophy aimed at agreement with ordinary linguistic intuitions or common sense beliefs, or both. All of these aspects of the subject sit uneasily with the use of historical texts for philosophical illumination. In this book, ten distinguished philosophers explore the tensions between, and the possibilities of reconciling, analytic philosophy and history of philosophy.Contributors: M. R. Ayers, John Cottingham, Daniel Garber, Gary Hatfield, Anthony Kenny, Steven Nadler, G. A. J. Rogers, Tom Sorell, Catherine Wilson, Yves Charles Zarka
This volume investigates the inherent tension between the methodology of analytic philosophy and the practice of historical philosophical inquiry. Editors G. A. J. Rogers and Tom Sorell assemble a collection of essays from ten prominent philosophers to examine whether the rigorous, science-oriented, and often ahistorical nature of analytic philosophy can be reconciled with the study of historical texts. The work addresses the fundamental conflict between the analytic demand for clarity and precision and the interpretive requirements of historical scholarship.
What You Will Find
Experts identify this collection as a significant contribution to the meta-philosophical debate regarding the identity and boundaries of analytic philosophy. Readers frequently note the academic density of the prose, which serves as a foundational text for those interested in the intersection of historical methodology and modern analytical rigor.
Page Count:
240
Publication Date:
2005-06-02
Publisher:
Clarendon Press
ISBN-10:
0199278997
ISBN-13:
9780199278992
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!