
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
The history of criminal justice in the U.S. is often described as a pendulum, swinging back and forth between strict punishment and lenient rehabilitation. While this view is common wisdom, it is wrong. In Breaking the Pendulum, Philip Goodman, Joshua Page, and Michelle Phelps systematically debunk the pendulum perspective, showing that it distorts how and why criminal justice changes. The pendulum model blinds us to the blending of penal orientations, policies, and practices, as well as the struggle between actors that shapes laws, institutions, and how we think about crime, punishment, and related issues.Through a re-analysis of more than two hundred years of penal history, starting with the rise of penitentiaries in the 19th Century and ending with ongoing efforts to roll back mass incarceration, the authors offer an alternative approach to conceptualizing penal development. Their agonistic perspective posits that struggle is the motor force of criminal justice history. Punishment expands, contracts, and morphs because of contestation between real people in real contexts, not a mechanical "swing" of the pendulum. This alternative framework is far more accurate and empowering than metaphors that ignore or downplay the importance of struggle in shaping criminal justice.This clearly written, engaging book is an invaluable resource for teachers, students, and scholars seeking to understand the past, present, and future of American criminal justice. By demonstrating the central role of struggle in generating major transformations, Breaking the Pendulum encourages combatants to keep fighting to change the system.
This book investigates whether the history of American criminal justice is best understood as a mechanical pendulum swinging between punishment and rehabilitation, ultimately arguing that it is not. The authors, Philip Goodman, Joshua Page, and Michelle Phelps, utilize a comprehensive re-analysis of two centuries of penal history to challenge the prevailing pendulum metaphor. They propose an 'agonistic' framework, positing that the evolution of criminal justice is driven by ongoing struggle and contestation between various social actors rather than cyclical, automatic shifts in policy.
What You Will Find
Experts and scholars in the fields of sociology and criminology recognize this work as a significant intervention in the study of penal history. Readers frequently note that the text provides a clear, accessible, and rigorous challenge to conventional wisdom, making it a valuable resource for academic discourse on criminal justice reform.
Page Count:
240
Publication Date:
2017-04-17
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0199976058
ISBN-13:
9780199976058