
Through A Detailed Analysis That Draws On Work Across Philosophy, The Law, And Social Psychology, This Book Shows That, From The Very Beginning Of The American Criminal Legal Process In Interrogation Rooms To Its Final Stages In Front Of Parole Boards, Testimony Is Extracted From Individuals Through Processes That Are Coercive, Manipulative, Or Deceptive. This Testimony Is Then Unreasonably Regarded As Representing The Testifiers' Truest Or Most Reliable Selves. With Chapters Ranging From False Confessions And Eyewitness Misidentifications To Recantations From Victims Of Sexual Violence And Expressions Of Remorse From Innocent Defendants At Sentencing Hearings, It Is Argued That There Is A Distinctive Epistemic Wrong Being Perpetrated Against Suspects, Defendants, Witnesses, And Victims. This Wrong Involves Brute State Power Targeting The Epistemic Agency Of Its Citizens, Extracting False Testimony That Is Often Life-shattering, And Rendering The Victims In Question Complicit In Their Own Undoing. It Is Concluded That It Is Only Through Understanding What It Means To Respect The Epistemic Agency Of Each Participant In The Criminal Legal System That We Can Truly Grasp What Justice Demands And, In So Doing, To Reimagine What Is Possible-- Provided By Publisher.
This book investigates the systemic epistemic wrongs perpetrated within the American criminal legal system by examining how state power extracts and misuses testimony from suspects, defendants, and victims. Jennifer Lackey, a professor of philosophy, synthesizes research from legal studies, social psychology, and epistemology to argue that the current legal framework systematically undermines the epistemic agency of individuals. She posits that the reliance on coerced or deceptive testimony creates a cycle of injustice that renders participants complicit in their own legal undoing.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Experts in legal philosophy and criminal justice reform recognize this work as a significant contribution to the study of testimonial injustice. Readers frequently note the academic density of the prose, which effectively bridges the gap between abstract philosophical theory and practical legal application.
Page Count:
0
Publication Date:
2023-01-01
ISBN-10:
0192679023
ISBN-13:
9780192679024
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!