
Constitutional law is clearly shaped by judicial actors. But who else contributes? Scholars in the past have recognized that the legislative branch plays a significant role in determining structural issues, such as separation of powers and federalism, but stopped there--claiming that only courts had the independence and expertise to safeguard individual and minority rights. In this readable and engaging narrative, the authors identify the nuts and bolts of the national dialogue and relate succinct examples of how elected officials and the general public often dominate the Supreme Court in defining the Constitution's meaning. Making use of case studies on race, privacy, federalism, war powers, speech, and religion, Devins and Fisher demonstrate how elected officials uphold individual rights in such areas as religious liberty and free speech as well as, and often better than, the courts.This fascinating debunking of judicial supremacy argues that nonjudicial contributions to constitutional interpretation make the Constitution more stable, more consistent with constitutional principles, and more protective of individual and minority rights.
Does the judiciary hold exclusive authority over the interpretation of the United States Constitution, or do elected officials and the public play a critical role in defining its meaning? Dr. Louis Fisher and Neal Devins challenge the doctrine of judicial supremacy by examining how the legislative and executive branches, alongside public discourse, actively shape constitutional law. The authors utilize historical analysis and legal theory to argue that nonjudicial actors are not only capable of protecting individual rights but often perform this function more effectively than the courts.
What You Will Find
Experts and legal scholars frequently cite this work as a critical counter-narrative to the traditional focus on judicial review. Readers note that the text provides an accessible yet rigorous challenge to the assumption that the Supreme Court is the sole arbiter of constitutional principles.
Page Count:
320
Publication Date:
2004-08-26
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0195171233
ISBN-13:
9780195171235
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!