
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Stepping Back From The Above Analysis, It Is Helpful To Ask Whether The Shift To A More Individualistic Conception Of Persons Carries Traction For Those Who Do Not Share Its Religious Underpinnings. Judeo-christian Personhood Was Grounded On The Idea That All And Only Human Beings Are Made In The Image Of God (imago Dei); For Contemporary Secular Philosophers, There Seems To Be No Corollary Justification For Claiming That All And Only Human Beings Qualify As Persons. Some Contemporary Christians, Such As Noonan, Have Sought To Defend An Exclusive Moral Status For Human Beings By Arguing That Possessing The Human Genetic Code Affords The Secular Underpinnings For Such A Position. Yet, This Proposal Was Eventually Rebuffed As 'speciesist.' 'speciesism,' A Term Coined In The 1970s By Ryder And Popularized By Singer, Is The Position That Assigning Moral Standing On The Basis Of Species Membership Is Morally Arbitrary.
This book investigates the philosophical and moral criteria used to define personhood in both religious and secular contexts. The authors, Caesar A. Atuire and Nancy Ann Silbergeld Jecker, utilize a comparative framework to examine how historical Judeo-Christian concepts of the 'imago Dei' have transitioned into modern secular debates. They analyze the logical consistency of grounding moral status in biological markers versus cognitive or relational capacities, specifically addressing the challenges posed by accusations of speciesism.
What You Will Find
Experts in bioethics and moral philosophy identify this text as a rigorous contribution to the ongoing debate regarding the definition of human moral status. Readers frequently note the academic density of the prose, which is well-suited for students and scholars navigating the intersection of theology and secular ethics.
Page Count:
0
Publication Date:
2025-01-01
Publisher:
New York, NY : Oxford University Press,
ISBN-10:
0197690955
ISBN-13:
9780197690956
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!