
Pundits have observed that if so many incumbents are returned to Congress to each election by such wide margins, perhaps we should look for ways to increase competitiveness – a centerpiece to the American way of life – through redistricting. Do competitive elections increase voter satisfaction? How does voting for a losing candidate affect voters’ attitudes toward government? The not-so-surprising conclusion is that losing voters are less satisfied with Congress and their Representative, but the implications for the way in which we draw congressional and state legislative districts are less straightforward.Redistricting and Representation argues that competition in general elections is not the sine qua non of healthy democracy, and that it in fact contributes to the low levels of approval of Congress and its members. Brunell makes the case for a radical departure from traditional approaches to redistricting – arguing that we need to "pack" districts with as many like-minded partisans as possible, maximizing the number of winning voters, not losers.
Does the pursuit of competitive elections actually undermine the health of American democracy and voter satisfaction? Thomas L. Brunell, a professor of political science, utilizes empirical data on congressional voting patterns and voter behavior to challenge the conventional wisdom that competitive districts are inherently beneficial. He argues that the current focus on creating competitive districts leads to higher numbers of dissatisfied voters, proposing instead a strategy of partisan packing to maximize the number of voters who feel represented by their elected officials.
What You Will Find
Scholars and political analysts frequently cite this work as a provocative contribution to the debate on electoral reform and gerrymandering. Readers often note the academic density of the prose, which relies heavily on statistical evidence to support its counterintuitive conclusions.
Page Count:
145
Publication Date:
2008-01-25
Publisher:
Routledge
ISBN-10:
0203929721
ISBN-13:
9780203929728
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!