
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
One of the most hotly-contested debates in contemporary democracy revolves around issues of political presence, and whether the fair representation of disadvantaged groups requires their presence in elected assemblies. Representation as currently understood derives its legitimacy from a politics of ideas, which considers accountability in relation to declared policies and programs, and makes it a matter of relative indifference who articulates political preferences or beliefs. What happens to the meaning of representation and accountability when we make the gender or ethnic composition of elected assemblies an additional area of concern? In this innovative contribution to the theory of representation--which draws upon debates about gender quotas in Europe, minority voting rights in the USA, and the multi-layered politics of inclusion in Canada--the author argues that the politics of ideas is an inadequate vehicle for dealing with political exclusion. But eschewing any essentialist grounding to group identity or group interest, she also argues against either/or choice between ideas and political presence. The work then combines with contemporary explorations of deliberative democracy to establish a different balance between accountability and autonomy.
This work investigates whether the legitimacy of democratic representation requires the physical presence of disadvantaged groups within elected assemblies. Anne Phillips, a prominent political theorist, examines the tension between the traditional 'politics of ideas' and the demand for descriptive representation. She argues that while the politics of ideas is insufficient to address systemic political exclusion, a move toward presence must avoid essentialist definitions of group identity, ultimately proposing a framework that balances accountability with group autonomy.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Scholars and political theorists frequently cite this text as a foundational contribution to the discourse on descriptive versus substantive representation. Readers often note the academic density of the prose, which is intended for an audience familiar with democratic theory and institutional analysis.
Page Count:
209
Publication Date:
1998-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press, Incorporated
ISBN-10:
0191520969
ISBN-13:
9780191520969
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!