
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
In the prevailing liberal ethos, if there is one thing that is beyond the reach of others, it is our body in particular, and our person in general: our legal and political tradition is such that we have the right to deny others access to our person and body, even though doing so would harm those who need personal services from us, or body parts. However, we lack the right to use ourselves as we wish in order to raise income, even though we do not necessarily harm others by doing so---even though we might in fact benefit them by doing so. Cécile Fabre's aim in this book is to show that, according to the principles of distributive justice which inform most liberal democracies, both in practice and in theory, it should be exactly the other way around: that is, if it is true that we lack the right to withhold access to material resources from those who need them, we also lack the right to withhold access to our body from those who need it; but we do, under some circumstances, have the right to decide how to use it in order to raise income. More specifically, she argues in favour of the confiscation of body parts and personal services, as well as of the commercialization of organs, sex, and reproductive capacities.
This book investigates whether the principles of distributive justice that govern material resources should also apply to the human body and personal services. Cécile Fabre, a professor of political philosophy, utilizes the framework of liberal egalitarianism to challenge traditional notions of bodily integrity. She argues that if individuals are obligated to share material wealth to assist others, a consistent application of these principles suggests a similar obligation to provide access to one's body parts or services, while simultaneously advocating for the right to commercialize bodily functions.
What You Will Find
Scope Limits
Scholars in political philosophy frequently note the provocative nature of Fabre's arguments, which challenge long-standing intuitions about bodily autonomy. Experts highlight this as a rigorous, albeit controversial, application of distributive justice that forces readers to confront the logical inconsistencies within modern liberal frameworks.
Page Count:
256
Publication Date:
2006-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0191537314
ISBN-13:
9780191537318
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!