
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Should a machine that emits harmful levels of pollution receive patent protection? Should pornography receive copyright protection? This book argues that certain intellectual creations should not receive patent or copyright protection on the grounds that those works are harmful to society. The book posits that the theories of intellectual property and the Intellectual Property Clause of the U.S. Constitution suggest this conclusion. It also considers several counterarguments: in particular, that denying protection might increase the output of objectionable works, that other laws should address moral problems, and that intellectual property functions better under a laissez-faire approach. Despite these counterarguments, the book contends that law should never encourage or reward harmful behavior. This simple principle implies that courts should exercise their equitable powers to deny enforcement of intellectual property for works involving unlawful conduct. It implies that courts should deny protection for works that clearly fall outside the Intellectual Property Clause's scope of protectable works. And it implies that Congress should consider denying protection for works that pose clear harms to society. The book also addresses the intersection between denying intellectual property protection and maintaining free speech protection. In that regard, the book recognizes that the Free Speech Clause severely limits Congress's discretionary authority to deny copyright protection for expression that it deems immoral. The book concludes that courts, Congress, and government agencies should exercise limited discretion in deciding whether certain intellectual works are morally eligible for intellectual property protection.
This book investigates whether intellectual property law should withhold patent and copyright protection from creations that are deemed harmful to society. Ned Snow, a legal scholar, examines the intersection of intellectual property theory and constitutional mandates to argue that the legal system should not incentivize or reward behavior that causes societal harm. By analyzing the U.S. Constitution's Intellectual Property Clause alongside moral and equitable principles, the author proposes a framework where courts and Congress exercise limited discretion to deny protection to objectionable works.
What You Will Find
Legal scholars and practitioners view this work as a significant contribution to the ongoing debate regarding the moral limits of intellectual property law. Readers frequently note the clarity with which the author navigates complex constitutional intersections between property rights and public policy.
Page Count:
360
Publication Date:
2021-12-21
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
019761440X
ISBN-13:
9780197614402
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!