
As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, Menrva Books earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Few problems call more urgently for a solution than that of hostility between different races: the survival of our civilization may well depend on it. Many people think this is a new issue, peculiar to our times, but, as Professor Lewis Hanke shows in this study, the debate was raging furiously four centuries ago in Spain, at that time approaching the zenith of its colonial power in the New World. The kernel of this book is the encounter between Juan Gines de Sepulveda and Bartolome de las Casas, a Dominican friar and author of a 'Historia general de las Indias' that is still an essential source book for the early history of Mexico. Their prolonged debate took place at Valladolid in 1550-51. Based on the doctrine propounded by Aristotle in his 'Politics' that some men are born to slavery, and on Aquinas's grounds for a just war, much of Sepulveda's defence of Cortes' methods of conquest and forcible conversion of the Indians to Christianity has today a frighteningly familiar ring. Las Casas declared these arguments to be in direct contradiction to the Gospels, to the laws of the Church and to his personal knowledge of the Indians. In tracing the ramifications of this debate in subsequent Spanish colonial policy and in the wider context of our own times, Professor Hanke has not only provided an absorbing analysis of one phase of a perennial human problem, but also done a valuable service in reminding us that there have always been men who will not temporize for the sake of expediency when they see wrong put forward as right.--Front inside flap of book jacket.
The question of whether some peoples are inherently suited for subjugation, and the justification of conquest and forced conversion, raged fiercely in 16th-century Spain. This book centers on the 1550-51 Valladolid debate between Juan Gines de Sepulveda, who argued for the natural enslavement of indigenous peoples based on Aristotelian doctrine, and Bartolomé de las Casas, a Dominican friar who countered these arguments as contrary to Christian teachings and his own observations. Professor Lewis Hanke traces the profound impact of this debate on Spanish colonial policy and its enduring relevance to contemporary issues of racial hostility and the defense of human rights against expediency.
This study is regarded as a significant historical analysis of a crucial ethical debate that shaped colonial policy and continues to resonate today. The book meticulously details the intellectual clash between Sepulveda and Las Casas, highlighting the philosophical underpinnings of their arguments and their profound implications. Hanke's work is noted for its thorough research and its ability to connect historical controversies to enduring questions of human rights and racial justice. It serves as a reminder of the historical precedents for contemporary struggles against oppression and the importance of ethical considerations in the face of political expediency.
Page Count:
164
Publication Date:
1959-01-01
ISBN-10:
0253201322
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!