
Most Americans imagine the Civil War in terms of clear and defined boundaries of freedom and slavery: a straightforward division between the slave states of Kentucky and Missouri and the free states of Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, and Kansas. However, residents of these Western border states, Abraham Lincoln's home region, had far more ambiguous identities-and contested political loyalties-than we commonly assume. In The Rivers Ran Backward, Christopher Phillips sheds light on the fluid political cultures of the Middle Border states during the Civil War era. Far from forming a fixed and static boundary between the North and South, the border states experienced fierce internal conflicts over their political and social loyalties. White supremacy and widespread support for the existence of slavery pervaded the free states of Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois, which had much closer economic and cultural ties to the South, while those in Kentucky and Missouri held little identification with the South except over slavery. Debates raged at every level, from the individual to the state, in parlors, churches, schools, and public meeting places, among families, neighbors, and friends. Ultimately, the pervasive violence of the Civil War and the cultural politics that raged in its aftermath proved to be the strongest determining factor in shaping these states' regional identities, leaving an indelible imprint on the way in which Americans think of themselves and others in the nation. The Rivers Ran Backward reveals the complex history of the Western border states as they struggled with questions of nationalism, racial politics, secession, neutrality, loyalty, and even place-as the Civil War tore the nation, and themselves, apart. In this major work, Phillips shows that the Civil War was more than a conflict pitting the North against the South, but one within the West that permanently reshaped American regions.
How did the fluid political and social identities of the Western border states complicate the traditional North-South dichotomy during the American Civil War? Christopher Phillips, a historian specializing in the American West and the Civil War era, examines the complex loyalties within Kentucky, Missouri, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, and Kansas. By analyzing primary source materials and regional political discourse, Phillips argues that these states functioned as a contested middle ground where economic ties and racial ideologies frequently defied simple nationalistic categorization. The work posits that the internal conflict within these states was as significant to the war's outcome as the primary military engagements between the Union and the Confederacy.
What You Will Find
Historians and scholars of the American Civil War frequently cite this work for its nuanced exploration of the border states, noting its departure from binary interpretations of the era. Readers often highlight the density of the research and the author's ability to synthesize complex local political shifts into a broader national narrative.
Page Count:
0
Publication Date:
2016-01-01
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
ISBN-10:
0199720177
ISBN-13:
9780199720170
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!